CS  ·  Computer Systems

Storage Devices

Lesson CS7 of 10 Approx 60 min Magnetic, optical and solid-state storage
Learning intentions
  • Understand the purpose of backing storage
  • Describe magnetic, optical and solid-state storage
  • Compare storage devices using suitable criteria for a scenario
Success criteria
  • I can state that backing storage is non-volatile and keeps data when power is off
  • I can identify examples of magnetic, optical and solid-state storage
  • I can compare devices using capacity, speed, durability, portability, reliability and cost
  • I can recommend a suitable storage device for a given user or task
Warm up — what do you already know?

Answer before the lesson begins. These check prior knowledge — it's fine if you're unsure.

1. Which word means that data is kept when power is switched off?

2. Which type of memory stores programs and data currently in use?

3. Why do computers need backing storage as well as RAM?

Key vocabulary

Backing storage
Non-volatile storage used to keep files, programs and data when power is off.
Storage device
Hardware used to read data from, or write data to, a storage medium.
Storage medium
The material or technology that actually stores the data, such as magnetic surface or flash memory.
Magnetic storage
Stores data using magnetised areas, for example hard disk drives and magnetic tape.
Optical storage
Stores data using marks read by laser light, for example CD, DVD and Blu-ray discs.
Solid-state storage
Stores data electronically in flash memory with no moving parts, for example SSDs and USB flash drives.
Capacity
The amount of data a storage device can hold, usually measured in GB or TB.
Portability
How easy it is to move the device or medium between computers or locations.

Storage Devices

Backing storage keeps data long term

In the last lesson, RAM was described as temporary memory for programs and data currently in use. Backing storage has a different job. It keeps files, programs and data when the computer is switched off. This makes backing storage non-volatile. Examples include the internal drive in a laptop, a USB flash drive, an external hard drive, a Blu-ray disc and a memory card.

Storage is usually slower than RAM, but it has a much larger capacity and costs less per gigabyte. A computer loads a program from storage into RAM when it needs to run it. When a file is saved, data is written from RAM back to storage so it can be kept for the future.

Device and medium

A storage device is the hardware that reads and writes data. A storage medium is what the data is stored on. Sometimes these are separate. For example, a DVD drive is the device and the DVD disc is the medium. Sometimes they are built together, such as a USB flash drive, where the device and flash memory are in one small object.

Magnetic storage

Magnetic storage uses magnetised areas to represent binary data. A hard disk drive (HDD) contains spinning magnetic platters and moving read/write heads. HDDs often have large capacity and a lower cost per gigabyte than solid-state drives. They are widely used for desktop computers, servers, backups and external drives.

The main weakness of HDDs is that they have moving parts. This can make them slower than SSDs and more vulnerable to damage if dropped while operating. Magnetic tape is another magnetic storage medium. It is very slow for finding one specific file, but it can have extremely high capacity and low cost, so it is still used for large backups and archives.

Optical storage

Optical storage uses a laser to read marks on a disc. Common examples are CD, DVD and Blu-ray. Optical discs are portable, low-cost and useful for distributing media or keeping a copy that is not easily changed. Some optical discs are read-only, while others can be written once or rewritten depending on the format.

Optical storage usually has lower capacity and slower access speed than HDDs or SSDs. Discs can also be scratched, and many modern laptops no longer include optical drives. This makes optical storage less common for everyday file transfer than it used to be, but it is still useful in some archive and media situations.

Solid-state storage

Solid-state storage stores data electronically in flash memory. It has no moving parts. Examples include solid-state drives (SSDs), USB flash drives and memory cards. SSDs are usually much faster than HDDs, so they are commonly used for operating systems and applications where speed matters. They are also quieter and more durable because they do not rely on spinning platters or moving heads.

USB flash drives and memory cards are very portable, which makes them convenient for moving files between devices. Their small size is also a risk: they can be lost easily. Solid-state storage can cost more per gigabyte than magnetic storage, especially at higher capacities, but the speed and durability often make it the best choice for modern computers.

Magnetic HDD, tape large capacity Optical CD, DVD, Blu-ray laser-read discs Solid-state SSD, USB, SD card fast, no moving parts No single storage type is always best: choose using the scenario criteria.

Choosing a storage device

Exam questions often describe a person or organisation and ask for a suitable storage device. A good answer should use the details in the scenario. For example, a photographer carrying files between locations may need portability and reasonable capacity, so a solid-state external drive or memory card may be suitable. A school server backup may need very high capacity and low cost, so magnetic tape or large external magnetic drives may be suitable.

Useful comparison criteria include capacity, speed, portability, durability, reliability and cost. Avoid vague statements such as "it is better". Instead, say why it is better for that situation: "An SSD is suitable for a laptop because it has no moving parts, so it is more durable when the device is carried around, and it has fast access speeds for loading programs."

TypeExamplesStrengthsLimitations
MagneticHDD, tapeLarge capacity; low cost per GBMoving parts; slower than SSD; can be damaged by shock
OpticalCD, DVD, Blu-rayPortable discs; cheap; useful for distribution/archiveLower capacity; slower; discs can scratch; drives less common
Solid-stateSSD, USB flash, memory cardFast; durable; portable; no moving partsCan cost more per GB; small devices can be lost

Worked examples

Example 1 — Choosing storage for a laptop

A pupil needs a new laptop that starts quickly and is carried between rooms each day. Which storage type is most suitable?

1
Look for scenario clues: starts quickly means fast access speed; carried around means durability matters.
2
An SSD is solid-state, so it has fast access speeds and no moving parts.
3
A strong answer is: SSD, because it is fast for loading the operating system and more durable in a portable laptop because it has no moving parts.
Example 2 — Identifying optical storage

A question describes a disc that is read using a laser. Which storage category is being described?

1
The clue is laser.
2
CDs, DVDs and Blu-ray discs are read using laser light.
3
The category is optical storage.
Example 3 — Comparing HDD and SSD

A desktop computer needs to store a very large video library at low cost. Compare HDD and SSD for this situation.

1
Choose relevant criteria: capacity and cost are the key clues in the question.
2
HDDs usually offer large capacity at a lower cost per gigabyte than SSDs.
3
A good comparison is: An HDD is likely more suitable because it can provide high capacity for the video library at lower cost, while an SSD would be faster but more expensive for the same capacity.
Now you try

A school wants to keep weekly backups of large amounts of data. The backups do not need to be opened often, but they must be kept safely for a long time and the cost should be low.

Answer the following:

  1. Which storage type would be suitable?
  2. Which two criteria from the scenario support your choice?
  3. Why might a very fast SSD not be the best choice here?
  1. Magnetic tape or a large magnetic backup drive would be suitable.
  2. The scenario needs high capacity and low cost, and the backups do not need to be accessed often.
  3. An SSD would be fast, but speed is not the main requirement. For very large backups it may cost more per gigabyte than magnetic storage.
Common mistakes
Writing "storage" when the question asks for a type. Name the category or device: magnetic HDD, optical Blu-ray, solid-state SSD, USB flash drive, and so on.
Saying SSDs are always best. SSDs are fast and durable, but HDDs or tape may be better where very high capacity and low cost matter most.
Confusing RAM with backing storage. RAM is volatile memory for current programs and data. Backing storage keeps files when power is off.
Giving generic advantages. "It is portable" only helps if portability matters in the scenario. Match every point to the user's needs.
Exam tip

For a recommend or justify question, use the scenario words in your answer. A two-mark answer usually needs a device and a reason: "A USB flash drive is suitable because it is portable and has enough capacity for transferring homework files." A comparison question should mention both devices and a shared criterion, such as speed or capacity.

Task Set

Questions 1-5 are auto-checked. Questions 6-9 are self-marked — write your answer, then reveal the model answer to check your work.

1. Which option is an example of solid-state storage? TYPE 1

2. Which storage type uses a laser to read data? TYPE 1

3. Which device is usually best for high-capacity, low-cost storage in a desktop computer? TYPE 1

4. What is a key advantage of solid-state storage compared with magnetic hard disks? TYPE 1

5. Which criterion is most important for a device used to carry homework files between school and home? TYPE 1

6. Describe one advantage and one disadvantage of magnetic hard disk drives. TYPE 2

A magnetic hard disk drive can have a large capacity and a low cost per gigabyte, so it is useful for storing lots of files. A disadvantage is that it has moving parts, so it can be slower than an SSD and more easily damaged if dropped while operating.

7. Explain why optical storage is less common for everyday file transfer than USB flash drives. TYPE 2

Optical discs such as CDs and DVDs usually have lower capacity and slower access speeds than USB flash drives. They can be scratched and many modern computers do not include optical drives. USB flash drives are small, portable, rewritable and work with many devices that have USB ports.

8. A video editor needs to work with large video files every day. Recommend a storage device for the computer's main working drive and justify your choice. TYPE 3

An SSD would be suitable for the main working drive. Video editing benefits from fast read/write speeds when opening, saving and previewing large files. An SSD has no moving parts and is usually faster than an HDD, so it can improve performance while editing. A large HDD could still be used alongside it for cheaper long-term storage of completed projects.

9. A museum wants to archive a large collection of files that will rarely be accessed. Cost is more important than speed. Recommend a storage type and justify your answer. TYPE 3

Magnetic storage, especially magnetic tape or large magnetic hard drives, would be suitable. The museum needs high capacity and low cost, and the files will rarely be accessed, so speed is less important. Magnetic tape is often used for archives and backups because it can store very large amounts of data at low cost.
Teacher notes — Shift+T to hide

Suggested timing: 60 minutes. Warm up 6 min; vocabulary 6 min; notes and storage comparison graphic 20 min; worked examples 10 min; now you try 5 min; task set 13 min.

Key misconception to address: Pupils often say "SSD is best" without using the scenario. Keep pushing them to choose criteria from the question: capacity, speed, portability, durability, reliability and cost.

Live demo suggestion: If available, show a USB flash drive, memory card, optical disc and an old HDD/SSD. Ask all pupils to identify the storage type and one suitable use for each.

Extension question: Why might an organisation use more than one storage type in the same system? Look for answers combining SSD for fast access and HDD/tape/cloud backup for capacity or resilience.

SQA command words covered: "state", "describe", "compare", "recommend", "justify".